At Caravaggio, you may not find the venerated artist, but it’s hard to miss this mural—a collage of children’s faces by Donald Baechler that holds your attention as you walk in. A curving acoustic ceiling frames the mural and pulls you into the room, doing the rarest thing in New York restaurants: letting people actually hear each other without shouting over the music. Ebony paneling offers a moment of calm between folded zinc panels and charcoal drawings by artist Beatrice Caracciolo, giving the restaurant a rhythm that feels considered without being stiff.